Did you say what he said was true?该句属于什么从句?为什么Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的?请分析,

来源：学生作业帮助网 编辑：作业帮 时间：2024/05/09 06:47:14
Did you say what he said was true?该句属于什么从句?为什么Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的?请分析,

Did you say what he said was true?该句属于什么从句?为什么Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的?请分析,
Did you say what he said was true?该句属于什么从句?
为什么Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的?请分析,

Did you say what he said was true?该句属于什么从句?为什么Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的?请分析,
Did you say what he said was true
that 和 what 都可以引导宾语从句 二者区别在于
what 引导宾语从句 可以在从句中做句子成分 如 主语 宾语,这里what在从句中做主语
that引导宾语从句 that 在从句中不做句子成分,that 只有在引导限制定语从句时 才在句子中做成分
这里不可以用that,what前也没必要加that

did you say that ... 的that 引导宾语从句，从句作say 的宾语，that在从句中不做成分，只引导从句。what he said was true是宾语从句了，其中what he said 是宾语从句中的主语从句，what引导主语从句，并在主语从句中作said的宾语。请问，加不加that有什么区别呢？没区别，that在引导动词后面的宾语从句时是可以省略的，这一点在口语和非正...

全部展开

did you say that ... 的that 引导宾语从句，从句作say 的宾语，that在从句中不做成分，只引导从句。what he said was true是宾语从句了，其中what he said 是宾语从句中的主语从句，what引导主语从句，并在主语从句中作said的宾语。

收起

宾语从句：你刚刚说他说的话是真的？有点绕，但没有错啊。what在主句和从句中分别充当成分。主句中，what是宾语（所以是宾语从句），在从句中充当主语。这是很典型的what引导宾语从句的例子。

what he said was true 在句子作宾语从句。在宾语从句中，what he said 作主语，或者说，主语从句作宾语从句的主语。
Did you say that what he said was true?这个句子就是错的！因为that, what 都是引导词，引导词不可连在一起用。

是宾语从句，做say的宾语。当然不对，that和what都是关连词，怎么可以用两个呢？

1. What 开始到句末是宾语从句。what he said 是主语从句。
2. Did you say that what he said was true? 这个句子不是错的。

把这个句子分解开来看就明白了：
Did you say......(你说过......)
what he said was true(这是个句子，在整个大句子中处于宾语的位置，是宾语从句。但这个宾语从句又是有what引导的名词性短语做主语，加系表结构构成的)
为辨别句子的正误，可以把what he said代换成it,所以前面仍然是需要that 引导的。
句子本身没...

全部展开

把这个句子分解开来看就明白了：
Did you say......(你说过......)
what he said was true(这是个句子，在整个大句子中处于宾语的位置，是宾语从句。但这个宾语从句又是有what引导的名词性短语做主语，加系表结构构成的)
为辨别句子的正误，可以把what he said代换成it,所以前面仍然是需要that 引导的。
句子本身没错。
如果是这样就错了：i know that what you said.因为在what he said 后面没有其他成分了。这属于纯名词性从句。得把that 去掉。

收起

没错，表示疑问：你说他之前说的是真的吗？如果非要说是什么从句，可以理解为定语从句，（what he said）——他说的，做定语那这个句子也是对的吗？ Did you say what he said was true? 能分析一下吗？谢谢！这要结合语境，如果两个人A跟B两人面对面，A正在说C说的是真的，而B很惊讶，迫不及待A说完就打断，可以这么用，此时（what he said 可以做宾语，...

全部展开

没错，表示疑问：你说他之前说的是真的吗？如果非要说是什么从句，可以理解为定语从句，（what he said）——他说的，做定语

收起

What did he say? What did you say? What did he _(say) to you yesterday? He asked “What did you say?变为间接引语 2.He looks a___.What did you say to him Do you still remember( ) A.that B what he said C did he say that D what did he say what did he say? what did he tell you?为什么“say”和“tell”不用过去式,“said”、“told”? Do you still remember ( A that he said.B what he said.C did he say that.D what did he say .Do you still remember( ..A.that he said B.what the matter isC.did he say that D.what did he say WHY what did you say man?咩意思` Can you tell me what did he say at the meeting?哪里错的 What did he ____ you to___ at the meeting?ask talktell speak ask speak tell say Do you still remember what he said 这句话后面能换成 what did he say 为什么? Have you forgotten___when he died?A how old he was B what he did say 选A还是B可以选B吗?what he did say,也是陈述语序呀,did起强调作用 Could you tell me ___ at the party A what does he say B what he says Cwhat he said D what did he sa what are you saying?what did you say?的区别 What did he say that he would do?求翻译 What did he say that he would do?求翻译